Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Characters & Shadows's avatar

This is a wonderfully useful problem because it names a failure that is common far beyond philosophy of science. We often begin by trying to explain one thing, then slowly adjust the object of explanation until we have explained something adjacent, easier, or more available, while still granting ourselves credit for the original task. What makes this especially interesting is its moral and intellectual subtlety. The shift is not always dishonest. Sometimes it happens because inquiry is alive: the target moves as our understanding improves. But the danger begins when we stop noticing the movement. Then explanation becomes a polished form of evasion.

A good account, in that sense, does not only explain well. It remains faithful to what it promised to explain.

Homo Viator's avatar

A very insightful reflection on how easily we end up explaining something different from what we originally set out to explain.

Ready for more?